+ Add Chrome Extension

Back to Blog Home

10 Pumpkin Pie Recipes That Are Total Crowd Pleasers

kristinabyas profile picture
Kristina ByasGuest Blogger
October 29, 2016 · 4.3k Views

People enjoy the holiday season because they get to spend quality time with their friends and family. But, they are also fond of this time of year because this short period is the only chance they get to enjoy some of their favorite holiday dishes. Although there are a variety of fixings that people find themselves cravins, from turkey and dressing to mashed potatoes and mac-n-cheese, people may look forward to dessert more than anything, especially if there is pumpkin pie.

lightbulb iconPumpkin-flavored everything is basically the epitome of fall. Check out Trader Joe's, Target, Whole Foods, Vons, and Safeway for pumpkin treats to satisfy your cold-weather desires. Don't forget to take a look at al the Best Pumpkin-Flavored Treats You Can Get This Fall!


10 Pumpkin Pie Recipes That Will Please All Your Guests pumpkin pie icon


1. Pumpkin Pie Cake

pumpkin pie cake

Source: Betty Crocker

It is not uncommon for people to not be able to decide what exactly they want for dessert. Sure pumpkin pie is an option, but when there is also cake sitting in front of you, you may find yourself panicking as you try to make a decision. With pumpkin pie cake, the decision is easy because you are getting the best of both worlds.

Recipe from Betty Crocker


2. Pumpkin Pie In A Jar

pumpkin pie in a jar

Source: Delish

Jar desserts have become quite popular over the years. If you want to break away from the traditional pumpkin pie, you can try pumpkin pie in jar. This recipe is simple and it's a cute way to serve everyone's favorite holiday dessert.

Recipe from Delish


3. Caramel Pumpkin Pie

caramel pumpkin pie

Source: Epicurious

Who doesn't love caramel and pumpkin? If you haven't tried these two ingredients together, prepare to have your mind blown. This recipe will result in a sweet pumpkin pie that you won't be able to get enough of. One can only hope that there will enough left for seconds.

Recipe from Epicurious


4. Chocolate Pumpkin Pie with Gingersnap Crust

chocolate pumpkin pie with gingersnap crust

Source: The Vintage Mixer

Next to pumpkin, one ingredient people love to see featured in their desserts in chocolate. Anyone who enjoys both chocolate and pumpkin will find that chocolate-swirled pumpkin pie is perfect way to combine two of their faves and add a gingersnap bite.

Recipe from The Vintage Mixer


5. Pumpkin Cheesecake with Oreo Crust

pumpkin cheesecake with oreo crust

Source: OMG Chocolate Desserts

There are many flavors of cheesecake that exist, so it shouldn't surprise anyone that they can have pumpkin cheesecake pie. Again, those who are indecisive about which dessert they want to enjoy over the holidays can appreciate this combination of rich cheesecake, sweet pumpkin pie, and a chocolatey Oreo crust.

Recipe from OMG Chocolate Desserts


cat pumpkin icon Check out our Best Stores for Holiday Decorations and Seasonal Decor for smart shopping this holiday season!


6. Pumpkin Pie Cinnamon Rolls

pumpkin pie cinnamon rolls

Source: Diethood

How is this to wake your family up on Halloween morning (or any morning, for that matter)? Let the sweet, pumpkin scent fill your home as these bake fresh in your oven. These cinnamon rolls go to show that pumpkin pie doesn't always have to be in pie form.

Recipe from Diethood


7. Bourbon Pumpkin Pie

bourbon pumpkin pie

Source: Gimme Some Oven

If you're a fan of bourbon, then you'll be a fan of this Bourbon Pumpkin Pie. There's a splash of bourbon in the pie and in the whipped cream topping if one splash is not enough for you. Enjoy this with your friends at a potluck Friendsgiving, and you're sure to be the favorite person of the night.

Recipe from Gimme Some Oven


8.  Eggnog Pumpkin Pie

eggnog pumpkin pie

Source: The Gracious Wife

In addition to pumpkin, the holiday season is the ideal time to indulge in one or several cups of eggnog. One fun recipe that you can try this year is an eggnog pumpkin pie. Like many of the other fun recipes, this one is sure to have your guests going back for more.

Recipe from The Gracious Wife


9. Apple Butter & Pumpkin Pie

apple butter pumpkin pie

Source: Taste of Home

There are a lot of things you can spread on toast or butter to make it taste good, but apple butter is truly one of the best. It may taste great on toast, but it is just as delicious, if not better, when it is thrown into a pumpkin pie. The nice thing that many people will appreciate about this dessert is that you are enjoying two popular fall flavors at simultaneously.

Recipe from Taste of Home


10. Pumpkin Pie Wontons

pumpkin pie wontons

Source: Tablespoon

Pumpkin pie wontons are definitely a twist on the traditional pumpkin pie, but a fun twist that is creative and interesting. Not only is there that great pumpkin flavor that people love, this dessert also features a creamy maple dip.

Recipe from Tablespoon

fall pumpkin recipes banner

best fall trade joe's products banner


kristinabyas profile picture
Kristina Byas is a Milwaukee native who has written for Female Intel, Shepherd Express, Scandalous Women and more. She suffers from a severe case of wanderlust and has difficulty purchasing items at full price. You can learn more about her by following her on Twitter: @KristinaByas
unashhNov 16, 2016
Look yummy!